|
PERSPECTIVES
The Six Keys to Achieving
Disciplined Execution
By Mark W. Womack
|
|
Disciplined Execution is a topic that I
believe is drop-dead crucial for all business people.
How important is Disciplined Execution
relative to the vision and goals of a business enterprise? Simply put,
there are few things that I think can even match its importance.
Disciplined Execution is the answer to “How
can we maximize the impact of our strategic initiatives?” It’s the
answer to “How can we get the most out of our resources?” Disciplined
Execution is the answer to “How can we realize our full potential?” And
finally, Disciplined Execution is the answer to “How do the best get
even better?”
The truth is that few achieve consistently
Disciplined Execution. It demands of us a fierce desire and focus and
an unrelenting will to achieve it. But it’s certainly achievable. So
how do you get it? How do you get all there is to get? I’ve broken the
answer to that question into Six Keys to Achieving Disciplined
Execution.
These Six Keys are applicable to every
aspect of an overall business. And no matter how mature or successful
your business is, applying these Keys will enable you to achieve
breakthrough performance gains.
Before I talk about the first of the Six
Keys, I’m going to whet your appetite with an example of what
world-class execution looks like.
Peyton Manning—the quarterback of the
Indianapolis Colts and the Most Valuable Player of the 2007 Super Bowl.
There are few leaders, regardless of industry, that better exemplify
what it means and what it takes to execute at the highest level than
Peyton Manning. And he does this under constant intense scrutiny and
while facing a type of competitive pressure that few of us will ever
experience.
So how does he do it? Sure, as he
humorously remarked in a TV commercial, he’s “6’5’’ with a rocket arm.”
But that’s only a minor part of the story. There’s a long list of NFL
& would-be NFL quarterbacks with equal or greater physical gifts. I
believe what sets him apart can be boiled down into two things:
First, he works at execution like nobody’s
business. In the history of the NFL, only a few QB’s have even rivaled
the extent to which he consistently prepares himself and his receivers
to execute the game plan.
Second, he never lets up. And I mean never. He’s
never satisfied by his previous best effort, even if it’s never been
equaled by anyone else. He’s constantly working, constantly refining,
constantly focused on the pursuit of flawless execution. Of course he
never achieves truly flawless execution, but the drive to get as close
as possible makes him an execution icon.
For the specific purpose of this article,
it’ll be helpful to have a simple but spot-on definition of Disciplined
Execution. At its core, Disciplined Execution is:
Consistently doing the right
things in the right ways in accordance with your mission, vision and
values
Now with that definition in mind:
The first of the Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution is:
Be unreasonable…Be
unreasonable when setting performance and behavioral standards and
expectations.
I’m a big advocate of being unreasonable in
terms of business leadership. The great thinker and writer George
Bernard Shaw said long ago that:
“The reasonable man adapts himself to the
world; the unreasonable man persists in trying to adapt the world to
himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.”
It’s Mr. Shaw’s inspiring version of the
unreasonable man or woman that I’m talking about here because I believe
that Mr. Shaw absolutely hit the nail on the head.
Was Jack Welch reasonable when he declared
that GE would become #1 or 2 in every market they serve – no matter
what? Mr. Welch was clearly out of his mind. And then GE became #1 or 2
in every market they served.
Was Walt Disney reasonable when he declared
that they would build a pristine Magic Kingdom that would deliver
happiness to everyone who entered? At the time that Mr. Disney
envisioned what would become Disneyland, the image of the amusement
park industry was a brand manager’s dream—filthy, unsafe and deceptive.
In fact, the inspiration for Walt Disney’s
vision came while he sat on a bench watching his young daughters at an
amusement park. On that bench, he began to think about how much better it
could be. Looking back, it’s a wonder he wasn’t locked up for
having such radical ideas long before he could finish the job.
In the 1940’s, about a decade before
Disneyland opened, some very unreasonable thinking was bubbling up in
Northern California. At that time, an academic institution by the name
of Stanford was a very fine university but was not on the short-short
list of the very best of elite American universities. On the other side
of the country, Harvard was definitely on that short-short
list.
Stanford’s top leadership put a deep stake
in the ground about the long-term brand they would build. They declared
that they would become the “Harvard of the West.” Once they did this,
it guided all of their thoughts & actions from that day forward.
So what happened? They not only achieved
this overarching goal in-full many years ago, today there are even
those who dare consider Harvard the “Stanford of the East.”
The point of the Stanford story is the same
as can be gleaned from the Jack Welch story and the Walt Disney story.
Our futures are predominately determined by two things:
1. The magnitude of our ambition
2. Our level of commitment to relentlessly
executing our way to it
All extraordinary organizations
begin with such unreasonable ambitions that win the hearts and minds of
an organization’s people.
But the real secret to the success of Jack
Welch, Walt Disney and the leaders of Stanford is what they did after
they declared their audacious goals. They were just as unreasonable
when translating their seemingly outrageous goals into what people were
expected to do and how they were
expected to do it. They understood that this was crucial in order for
their organizations to make the leap they envisioned. They knew that it
was these expectations that would drive the performance and behavior of
the organization to the desired results.
With Key #1, a foundation for
Disciplined Execution is established by setting the bar unreasonably
high.
The second of the Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution is:
Get everybody on the Same
Page.
Sadly so, this is where most organizations
trip not too long after leaving the starting blocks. “Everybody on the
same page” means that the performance and behavior of the entire organization
is inspired and guided by the same goals. Every individual
exception to this reduces efficiency and effectiveness—and undermines
the organization’s drive to realize its full potential. Worse yet,
these individual exceptions negate some of the forward momentum made by
those who are on the right page.
The two most important things that leaders
need to do to “get everybody on the same page” are:
1. Frequently
communicate their vision
2. “Show the way” by consistently role-modeling the desired performance and behavior
The first of two powerful examples that
personify what getting “everybody on the same page” is all about comes
from Bill Belichick, the Head Coach of the New England Patriots. How
does he do it? The answer is primarily three-fold.
First, his process for screening potential
team members is unwavering in its criteria. He might take a skilled
player who was problematic elsewhere, but he won’t take a player if
he’s not confident the player will live up to the standards and
expectations once he’s become a New England Patriot.
Secondly, every new member of the Patriots
is immediately immersed in the Patriot values and ways by both coaches
and teammates. This is never left to chance.
And last, once you know what page a Patriot
is supposed to be on, you’re either on it, or you don’t play and you’re
not a Patriot for long, no matter who you are. The result of
all this is an exceptionally tight knit organization that’s at or near
the top of the NFL pecking order every year, even when their overall
talent level is below that of many of their competitors.
The second example is from the gold
standard of upscale department stores. It’s probably not news that the
Nordstrom brand is all about elite service. What you may not know is
their powerful but simple mechanism for getting “everybody on the same
page.”
It’s impossible to sustain their brand
without getting “everybody on the same page.” This is so because
customers who expect elite service expect it every time—without
exception. The only way to meet and exceed such expectations is by
getting “everybody on the same page” to prevent any cracks or breaks in
the brand.
Their industry-leading success in doing
this is largely based on an incredibly simple customer service
philosophy coupled with highly empowered front-line personnel. Both
aspects are articulated in their legendary one-page Employee Handbook.
It says, and I quote: “Our #1 goal is to provide outstanding customer
service.” It also says, “Rule #1 is to use your good judgment in all
situations,” followed by “There will be no additional rules.” The
result of the one-page handbook is clarity of purpose few companies
achieve. The result: “Everybody on one page, based on one brand. And a
cult customer following who enthusiastically pay above premium.
With Key #2, momentum is
accelerated by getting “everybody on the same page.”
The third of the Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution is:
Pay attention...Pay
attention to how things are being done in the day-to-day aspects of
organization performance.
Setting unreasonable standards and
expectations and getting everybody on the same page is just the
beginning. In order to achieve Disciplined Execution,
organization leaders must then continuously pay attention to
how the organization is actually doing things day-to-day vs.
standards & expectations. This is necessary for the organization to
achieve mastery of the key activities in support of its competitive
strategies.
It’s not enough to evaluate performance in
regular review meetings. Too much of what’s behind the numbers is
missed or glossed over. Many of the most valuable opportunities
to gauge and refine an organization’s performance and behavior happen
real-time in the course of the day-to-day activities that are the
lifeblood of the organization.
One organization that epitomizes this level
of “paying attention” quietly became an industry leader when almost no
one was looking. I’m talking about Harrah’s Entertainment. Harrah’s has
grown to become the world’s largest provider of branded casino
entertainment. Their CEO, Gary Loveman, was recently named Best CEO in
his industry for the fourth year in a row by Institutional Investor
magazine. That’s every year he’s been Harrah’s CEO.
Harrah’s distinguishes themselves through
Disciplined Execution. New employees are often surprised by
management’s insistence that nothing be left to chance. Each aspect of
a property’s service delivery—the average time to greet a customer or
to deliver a drink—is measured and reported on a weekly basis.
What are the results of this mindset and
commitment?
In 2006, Casino Player magazine’s
annual reader survey revealed Harrah’s properties winning 82 of the 168
possible “Top Three” rankings across 56 categories.
And their financial track record includes
rapid growth coupled with stellar bottom-line financial performance,
especially in this decade. Last year, their financial performance
ultimately led to one of the largest leveraged buyout offers in
history. That offer is awaiting approval as of this writing.
With Key #3, mastery of the key
activities in support of the organization’s competitive strategies is
attained by “paying attention.”
The fourth of the Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution is:
Be constructively
intolerant…Be constructively intolerant about performance and behavior
variances related to Disciplined Execution—every time.
In order to realize its full potential, an
organization must be “constructively intolerant” of performance and
behavior that’s counter to its aspirations. This means that the
organization must refuse to accept less than the performance
and behavior that is necessary. It’s crucial that this
unwillingness be absolutely consistent—no exceptions. It may
sound harsh—but it’s not. Such consistency breeds confidence. And it
says “This is who we are and this is how we do things.”
It’s important that the intolerance for
performance or behavior variances be “constructive.” To illustrate what
I mean I’ll compare the approaches of two football coaches. Coach A
yells at a struggling receiver in practice and tells him to catch the
ball or he’ll find someone who will. Then the coach moves on to yell at
someone else who’s screwing up. In the same situation, Coach B stops
play and provides specific coaching to the receiver about how to fix
flaws in his technique that were causing the problems. Both coaches are
intolerant of less than what is needed but Coach B approaches it more
constructively and gets faster and better results. Coach B will also be
in a better position than Coach A to know when someone simply isn’t
capable of doing what’s asked.
Despite its recent market challenges, one
of the best-executing big companies of the past quarter century is
Dell. Launched by Michael Dell in 1984 with only $1,000 in starting
capital, Dell grew to $50B in little over 20 years. In contrast, Compaq
was launched 2 years earlier with $100M in capital.
Dell’s phenomenal success can be traced to
a great business model + unreasonably high expectations + an
execution-obsessed culture that symbolizes “constructive intolerance.”
“Constructive intolerance” is so ingrained in their DNA that Dell
Managers who try to spin or hide problems or who aren’t urgent about
fixing them can’t survive. The execution obsessed culture won’t accept
them.
Regarding Dell’s recent earnings slippage,
Michael Dell reassumed the role of CEO on January 31st, 2007 and vowed
to get the business back on track. And what did he say would be his
overarching strategy for achieving that? Mr. Dell was right on cue. He
said that the key would be “to...improve execution.”
Another leader who represents the ideals of
good execution in general and “constructive intolerance” in particular
is John Wooden. His resume as the former coach of the UCLA Bruins
basketball team is unequaled. 10 NCAA Championships in 12 years. Seven
in a row.
Coach Wooden certainly recruited many great
players but so have many other coaches. What set him apart was his
“constructive intolerance” of variances to the principles of behavior
that he believed would lead to success.
One of the countless times that Coach
Wooden demonstrated this is when the great Bill Walton showed up for
the first practice of a season with both a hair length and beard not
meeting team standards. Walton had just come off a year in which he was
the centerpiece of an undefeated team and had been the NCAA Player of
the Year. Walton figured he had the leverage to test the principles of
the legendary coach.
When Coach Wooden immediately addressed the
issue with him, Walton told him that he didn’t have the right to tell
him how to wear his hair or whether he could have facial hair. Coach
Wooden said “you’re absolutely right Bill...and…I have a lot of respect
for people who stand up for the things in which they truly believe…and
we’re going to miss you Bill.”
Walton decided to exercise his personal
freedom by hurrying to get a haircut and a shave.
With Key #4, a winning mindset is
forged by “constructive intolerance” of anything that gets in the way
of Disciplined Execution.
The fifth of the Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution is:
Be flexible about
everything that doesn’t require Disciplined Execution.
Organizations that are constructively
intolerant of performance or behavior that is counter to their
aspirations also benefit greatly if they are simultaneously quite
“flexible about everything that doesn’t require Disciplined Execution.”
Not everything organization members do
requires Disciplined Execution. In fact, there are many things
organization members do that are best left to each individual to
determine the best methods relative to their unique strengths, talents
and style.
Southwest Airlines is a company that really
gets this. While their flight attending crews operate in a machine-like
manner when executing a variety of tasks, they are also empowered to be
themselves while working and serving their customers. The result is a
relaxed and fun environment while you savor your seven peanuts and
miniature beverage. When Herb Kelleher, their Chairman, was asked why
many Southwest flight attendants sing, he said it was “because they
want to.” He said “We don’t…teach people to sing or tell jokes. What we
say is, if that is your…personality, feel free to go ahead and do it.”
There are few areas of a business that
aren’t made better by harnessing this powerful synergy. An organization
that’s constructively intolerant and greatly empowering is a force that
no competitor wants to face.
So with Key #5, the benefits of
Disciplined Execution are maximized by being flexible in the areas that
don’t require it.
The sixth of the Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution is:
Behave As-If.
To realize a vision, organizations need to
continuously answer four critical questions relative to the future
image they have of themselves:
1. What would we do if
we were the organization we aspire to be?
2. What wouldn’t we do
that we’re currently doing?
3. How would we think?
4. How would we behave?
Organizations can only realize their
potential by consciously and continuously molding their thinking and
behavior to the future image they have of themselves—until the image
and the reality are one and the same.
A fantastic example of the power of
behaving “as-if” occurred in the days leading up to Super Bowl III, in
January of 1969. As the quarterback of the underdog New York Jets, Joe
Namath played a huge role in inspiring his team to a historic upset of
the Baltimore Colts. And I’m not talking about his dramatic declaration
that the Jets would defeat the supposedly unbeatable Colts. I’m talking
about what happened from the moment that he made his proclamation,
three days before the game, up until the end of the game.
Joe Namath didn’t behave like a guy who
brazenly shot off his mouth but was really just whistling in the
graveyard to keep his fears at bay. Everything about his behavior and
appearance suggested a quarterback who would be on the winning side. He
“behaved as-if.” And I believe this had a profound impact on the game’s
outcome.
One of my favorite examples of “behaving
as-if” ironically features one of the world’s most acclaimed actors. As
a young man, Al Pacino committed himself to be an actor. Once he did
this, he envisioned everything about the actor he wanted to become. He
created a picture in his mind of the whole thing. Not only that he
would be a great actor who would win major awards and be famous. That
alone wouldn’t be an unusual dream for an aspiring actor. The picture
Al created in his mind included every detail that he deemed important.
And then he did what inspires me to tell you this story.
From that time forward, he committed
himself to thinking and behaving as he thought the man in the picture
would. He approached his craft as the man would. He walked and talked
as the man would. He read what that man would read and so on. The real
test of his commitment was regarding what roles he would pursue and
accept when he was poor and unknown. I learned that he wouldn’t take
any part that the man in the picture wouldn’t take. He was steadfast
about this no matter how much he could use the money. I think he
somehow understood that you can’t fake your way to such greatness. The
result: he ultimately became the man in the picture and has sustained
one of the movie industry’s longest runs as a top-tier actor.
Think about the ambitious expectations for
your own organization. To “behave as-if” means constantly asking
yourselves how the organization that soars over that expectation
high-bar would think and behave. And you’re asking yourselves that
until you look up and realize you’re looking back from the far side of
that bar.
Now what does it take to excel at the Six
Keys I’ve just shared with you? It takes a lot. It takes a lot of your
time and energy. It takes a lot of effort. So is it worth all that?
I’ll make you an ironclad promise. A
promise I would never make to you if I had even the smallest doubt
about it whatsoever. This is my promise: you will earn three
exceptional rewards if you focus on the six keys I’ve shared with you.
1: You will become even smarter,
and more importantly, wiser —every day.
It’s literally impossible to focus on
these six things without becoming even smarter and wiser every day.
With every passing day, you will see things you didn’t see before. You
will understand things you didn’t understand before. You will solve
problems you didn’t even know were problems before.
2: Your business will perform at
unprecedented levels.
This is a no-brainer. Your business will
continuously refine itself and perform better and more efficiently than
its previous bests. Your business will become even stronger every day.
3: Your top and bottom-line will
grow.
They will grow proportionate to the
effort you invest in achieving Disciplined Execution of the right
things. Business sense dictates that if you’re committed to a vision
that’s better than you are today and you achieve Disciplined Execution
of the things that are critical to the realization of that vision—you
will grow the business. And since Disciplined Execution always
yields tremendous gains in efficiency and in doing it right the first
time—your bottom-line will grow even faster than your top line will.
Here’s an analogy that will connect the
dots between the things I’ve shared with you:
Now imagine you’re 23 years old and you’re
at a social gathering with many friends. Everybody’s having a great
time enjoying each other’s company and the food and spirits.
And then out of nowhere it happens. One of
the guys at the gathering accidentally drops an almost full bottle of
beer on the floor and it rapidly begins to spill out. Every guy within
earshot of this horrible accident has the same primal response—a
visceral urge to grab the capsized bottle and turn it right-side up as
soon as possible to minimize the tragedy before it’s too late.
One of the guys immediately swoops down
with Olympian skill and saves the innocent bottle after only a small
amount of the beverage had spilled. All who witnessed the feat admired
both his courage and athleticism. Some admired his apparent commitment
to conservation. And every one of the men admired him for upholding
their code in a time of distress.
What was their code? You know what it was.
You never, ever waste a drop of beer. Now for our purposes, the great
lesson comes from understanding the motivation behind the code. It’s
not borne of cost-consciousness or a lack of sufficient current supply
of the tasty beverage. They could afford more and they had more than
they would need for the gathering.
The motivation for the code was borne from
their wisdom that a wasted beer is a loss that cannot really
be replaced. You can take another from your supply or you can purchase
more. But you can never enjoy the one that was wasted. It’s a missed
opportunity.
It’s exactly the same thing with business
execution. No matter how hard you work and no matter how much you
achieve, if you don’t have Disciplined Execution of the right
things—you will leave a lot on the table. As with wasted beer, the
result is missed opportunities.
But if you achieve Disciplined Execution of
the right things, you get the most out of your resources. You get all
there is to get. You become the best you can be. And then you become
better than that.
Exhibit A of someone who exemplifies this
constant drive, no pun intended, is Tiger Woods. Tiger has
been widely considered the best golfer on the planet since shortly
after he joined the PGA tour as a young man. After already reaching
this level, he significantly rebuilt his golf swing—twice! The first
time was about 10 years ago and the second time was about four years
ago. Think about it. You’re the best in the world.
Many think it’s only a matter of time before you’re statistically the
best that ever played…and you feel the need to fix your
swing!!! There’s only one answer to why someone would engage in such
sheer madness. The answer is he’s not trying to be the best—again, he
already was—no, Tiger’s on a very different quest. He’s on a
never-ending quest to be better then himself.
And what happened after he made the changes
to his swing? Both times, once he achieved Disciplined Execution,
the best in the world got even better.
—MWW
Click here for the PDF version of "The Six Keys to
Achieving Disciplined Execution," including a printable poster of
the "Six Keys" on page 15